Skip to content
CIEM Tools

CIEM vs IAM: IAM grants and enforces access, CIEM audits what that access adds up to

IAM is the cloud provider's service that authenticates identities and authorizes requests through policies. CIEM reads those policies across accounts and clouds, resolves what they allow in practice, and compares it with what was used. AWS supports nine policy types, so a single role's effective access can come from several places.

See the ranking ยท All guides

IAM makes the decision for each request

AWS documentation describes IAM as a web service that helps you control who is authenticated and authorized to use resources. Access management, which AWS also calls authorization, works by attaching policies to identities or resources, and AWS evaluates those policies each time a principal makes a request. Azure does the same with role assignments, and Google Cloud does it with role bindings in allow policies. Each provider prices and counts its grants differently, as the CIEM pricing page shows.

IAM is therefore the enforcement point. It answers a narrow question quickly and correctly: is this request allowed. It does not report on grants nobody has used, and it does not tell you what a compromised role could reach across accounts.

One role's access can come from nine policy types

The AWS documentation on policies and permissions says AWS supports nine types of policies: identity-based policies, resource-based policies, VPC endpoint policies, permissions boundaries, Organizations service control policies, Organizations resource control policies, access control lists, Resource Access Manager shares and session policies. The effective result for one role depends on how these combine.

Azure adds another layer. Microsoft's role-based access control documentation says Azure RBAC is an additive model, so effective permissions are the sum of role assignments, and role assignments are transitive for groups. A user who is a member of a group that is a member of another group inherits the assignments of both. A CIEM tool does this arithmetic for you across every identity. See excess permission.

Where the line sits

The provider's own tools now cross the line. AWS IAM Access Analyzer has an unused access analyzer inside the IAM service, and Google's IAM recommender compares granted roles with 90 days of use. AWS IAM Access Analyzer scores 3.0 and Google Cloud IAM recommender scores 4.0 on the main view of this index, with Google third overall.

TopicIAM (provider service)CIEM (tool on top)
DecisionAllows or denies each requestDoes not sit in the request path
ScopeOne provider, often one account at a timeSeveral accounts and clouds in one view
QuestionIs this request permittedWhat can this identity do, and what did it use
OutputPolicies, roles, logsFindings, effective permissions, recommended changes
Who changes accessWhoever holds IAM write permissionThe tool, if it enforces; otherwise your team

Wiz's framing of the gap, and a caution

Wiz's CIEM guidance says traditional IAM systems answer administrative questions such as which roles are assigned, who approved access and when it was granted, but do not continuously answer which identities can actually reach critical resources and how. That is a vendor describing the problem its product solves, though the AWS and Azure documentation above supports the underlying point that effective access is a sum of many sources.

Buying CIEM does not replace IAM. You still write policies in IAM, and the tool's findings are only useful if someone changes them. The test of a CIEM product is whether it removes the excess, which is what the method scores first, at a weight of 25 of 100.

Sources

  1. AWS documentation, what is IAM, read 16 Nov 2026
  2. AWS documentation, policies and permissions, read 16 Nov 2026
  3. Microsoft Learn, what is Azure RBAC, read 16 Nov 2026
  4. Google Cloud, IAM roles and permissions, read 16 Nov 2026
  5. AWS documentation, IAM Access Analyzer, read 16 Nov 2026
  6. Google Cloud, IAM role recommendations overview, read 16 Nov 2026
  7. Wiz Academy, how to choose a CIEM vendor, read 16 Nov 2026

Last reviewed 16 Nov 2026.