# AWS IAM Access Analyzer vs Google Cloud IAM recommender: Google Cloud IAM recommender removes more access, 4.0 to 3.0

Facts read 10 Nov 2026. Page reviewed 16 Nov 2026.

Google Cloud IAM recommender beats AWS IAM Access Analyzer on the Least Privilege Index, 4.0 against 3.0. Across the five buyer situations Access Analyzer wins 0, IAM recommender wins 5. Every score on this page was read from the evidence on 10 Nov 2026 and links to its source.

### Behind on the index: AWS IAM Access Analyzer (3.0)
Provider tool, ahead on 1 of 7
9th of 14 on the Least Privilege Index (3.00 before rounding).
[Access Analyzer profile](/platforms/aws-iam-access-analyzer/)

### Ahead on the index: Google Cloud IAM recommender (4.0)
Provider tool, ahead on 5 of 7
3rd of 14 on the Least Privilege Index (3.95 before rounding).
[IAM recommender profile](/platforms/google-iam-recommender/)

**Where Act is behind.** Act is not a CNAPP: it does not scan workloads or vulnerabilities (none found on 2026-11-10), and it publishes no pricing. It also does not make the change itself: it has read-only access to your cloud and delivers each change as a pull request to your Terraform or CloudFormation, or as a ticket, for your team to apply, and handling of violations and time-bound waivers after a change ships was described as roadmap.

## The seven criteria side by side

| Criterion | Weight | Access Analyzer | IAM recommender | Ahead |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Removes access, not only reports it | 25 | 3 | 4 | IAM recommender |
| Safe to enforce | 20 | 4 | 6 | IAM recommender |
| One change, a class of risk | 15 | 1 | 3 | IAM recommender |
| Stays fixed | 15 | 4 | 2 | Access Analyzer |
| Identity, network and AI access together | 10 | 2 | 4 | IAM recommender |
| Uses the cloud's own controls | 10 | 4 | 5 | IAM recommender |
| Evidence for auditors | 5 | 2 | 2 | level |

AWS IAM Access Analyzer 3.0 (3.00), Google Cloud IAM recommender 4.0 (3.95) on the index weights.

## Why each scores what it scores

- **Removes access.** Access Analyzer 3: Refined policies and delete links are generated, and the user attaches or deletes them. IAM recommender 4: A person checks and applies role recommendations in the product. Organization policy recommendations are suggestions only.
- **Safe to enforce.** Access Analyzer 4: The tool previews a policy's effect on public and cross-account access and checks new access against the existing version. It does not simulate the impact of removal, and generated policies omit data events and PassRole. IAM recommender 6: Simulators show how an allow-policy change affects principals' access, and list resources that would violate a proposed organization policy before enforcement. Each simulator covers one policy type, and only Google Cloud.
- **One change, a class of risk.** Access Analyzer 1: Access Analyzer only reads RCPs. No boundary generation is listed. IAM recommender 3: Simulators exist for deny and Principal Access Boundary policies, and organization policies are recommended, but clean-up is done role by role.
- **Stays fixed.** Access Analyzer 4: Custom policy checks run before deployment in CI/CD and can trigger approval workflows. No drift or exception handling was found. IAM recommender 2: Recommendation states are tracked inside the product. The pre-deploy Terraform check is a separate tool, and no ticketing or chat integration was found.
- **Identity, network and AI.** Access Analyzer 2: Only identity unused access and resource-based policies are covered. No network or AI model is covered. IAM recommender 4: Identity role recommendations and a VPC Service Controls troubleshooter are provided. No AI workloads are covered.
- **Cloud's own controls.** Access Analyzer 4: It generates native IAM policies from CloudTrail and is not in the request path. It works in one cloud only, and the user applies the result. IAM recommender 5: A recommendation is an operation that removes a member from native IAM policy bindings. It works in one cloud only.

## What would change this ranking

AWS IAM Access Analyzer would move ahead of Google Cloud IAM recommender if its score on removes access rose by 4 points (from 3 to 7) with nothing else changing. A score changes only when a sourced fact changes, and every change is listed on the corrections page.

## Verdict by situation

- **An AWS-heavy organization with hundreds of accounts and years of accumulated access.** IAM recommender leads, 3.9 against 2.9. [The full ranking for this situation](/best-for/aws-scale/).
- **A multi-cloud enterprise with separate teams per cloud.** IAM recommender leads, 3.9 against 3.0. [The full ranking for this situation](/best-for/multi-cloud/).
- **A regulated company that must prove access boundaries for PCI DSS, HIPAA or NIST 800-53.** IAM recommender leads, 3.7 against 3.0. [The full ranking for this situation](/best-for/regulated/).
- **A company putting AI agents into production this year.** IAM recommender leads, 4.0 against 2.9. [The full ranking for this situation](/best-for/ai-agents/).
- **A small cloud security team buried under posture findings it cannot clear.** IAM recommender leads, 3.8 against 2.9. [The full ranking for this situation](/best-for/small-team/).

## Strongest, in one sentence each

- **AWS IAM Access Analyzer:** IAM Access Analyzer generates an IAM policy from up to 90 days of CloudTrail activity and recommends refined policies for unused permissions.
- **Google Cloud IAM recommender:** The IAM recommender suggests removing or replacing IAM roles that principals have not used, and Policy Simulator shows the effect of a policy change before it is made.

## Related pages

- [Removes access, not only reports it: the 14 platforms compared](/compare/criteria/removes/)
- [Safe to enforce: the 14 platforms compared](/compare/criteria/safe/)
- [One change, a class of risk: the 14 platforms compared](/compare/criteria/class/)
- [All of them](/compare/)

## Sources

- aws.amazon.com/iam/access-analyzer: https://aws.amazon.com/iam/access-analyzer/ (read 10 Nov 2026)
- docs.aws.amazon.com/IAM/latest/UserGuide/what-is-access-analyzer.html: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/IAM/latest/UserGuide/what-is-access-analyzer.html (read 10 Nov 2026)
- docs.aws.amazon.com/IAM/latest/UserGuide/access-analyzer-custom-policy-checks.ht: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/IAM/latest/UserGuide/access-analyzer-custom-policy-checks.html (read 10 Nov 2026)
- docs.aws.amazon.com/IAM/latest/UserGuide/access-analyzer-policy-generation.html: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/IAM/latest/UserGuide/access-analyzer-policy-generation.html (read 10 Nov 2026)
- cloud.google.com/policy-intelligence/docs/role-recommendations-overview: https://cloud.google.com/policy-intelligence/docs/role-recommendations-overview (read 10 Nov 2026)
- cloud.google.com/policy-intelligence/docs/organization-policy-recommendations-ov: https://cloud.google.com/policy-intelligence/docs/organization-policy-recommendations-overview (read 10 Nov 2026)
- cloud.google.com/policy-intelligence/docs/iam-simulator-overview: https://cloud.google.com/policy-intelligence/docs/iam-simulator-overview (read 10 Nov 2026)
- cloud.google.com/policy-intelligence/docs/overview: https://cloud.google.com/policy-intelligence/docs/overview (read 10 Nov 2026)

Last reviewed 16 Nov 2026. Canonical: https://ciemtools.com/compare/aws-iam-access-analyzer-vs-google-iam-recommender/
