P0 Security vs Google Cloud IAM recommender: Google Cloud IAM recommender removes more access, 4.0 to 3.1
Facts read 10 Nov 2026. Page reviewed 16 Nov 2026.
Google Cloud IAM recommender beats P0 Security on the Least Privilege Index, 4.0 against 3.1. Across the five buyer situations P0 wins 0, IAM recommender wins 5. Every score on this page was read from the evidence on 10 Nov 2026 and links to its source.
P0 profile ยท IAM recommender profile
Behind on the index
3.1
Just-in-time accessahead on 3 of 7
8th of 14 on the Least Privilege Index (3.05 before rounding).
P0 profileAhead on the index
4.0
Provider toolahead on 2 of 7
3rd of 14 on the Least Privilege Index (3.95 before rounding).
IAM recommender profile
Where Act is behind
Act is not a CNAPP: it does not scan workloads or vulnerabilities (none found on 2026-11-10), and it publishes no pricing. It also does not make the change itself: it has read-only access to your cloud and delivers each change as a pull request to your Terraform or CloudFormation, or as a ticket, for your team to apply, and handling of violations and time-bound waivers after a change ships was described as roadmap.
The seven criteria side by side
P0 Security 3.1 (3.05), Google Cloud IAM recommender 4.0 (3.95) on the index weights.| Criterion | Weight | P0 | IAM recommender | Ahead |
|---|
| Removes access, not only reports it | 25 | 5 | 4 | P0 |
| Safe to enforce | 20 | 0 | 6 | IAM recommender |
| One change, a class of risk | 15 | 2 | 3 | IAM recommender |
| Stays fixed | 15 | 3 | 2 | P0 |
| Identity, network and AI access together | 10 | 4 | 4 | level |
| Uses the cloud's own controls | 10 | 5 | 5 | level |
| Evidence for auditors | 5 | 3 | 2 | P0 |
P0 Security 3.1 (3.05), Google Cloud IAM recommender 4.0 (3.95) on the index weights.
Why each scores what it scores
- Removes access. P0 5: Just-in-time access is provisioned and revoked automatically, with history. Posture findings get suggested shell commands only. IAM recommender 4: A person checks and applies role recommendations in the product. Organization policy recommendations are suggestions only.
- Safe to enforce. P0 0: None found on 2026-11-10 after checking 20 pages. IAM recommender 6: Simulators show how an allow-policy change affects principals' access, and list resources that would violate a proposed organization policy before enforcement. Each simulator covers one policy type, and only Google Cloud.
- One change, a class of risk. P0 2: A deny-all policy blocks access requests made through the product for an account. It is not a cloud boundary. IAM recommender 3: Simulators exist for deny and Principal Access Boundary policies, and organization policies are recommended, but clean-up is done role by role.
- Stays fixed. P0 3: Requests arrive through Slack, findings go to Jira, and a Terraform provider exists. No pre-production check or drift handling is described. IAM recommender 2: Recommendation states are tracked inside the product. The pre-deploy Terraform check is a separate tool, and no ticketing or chat integration was found.
- Evidence for auditors. P0 3: P0 provides a full action-chain audit trail and a SOC 2 case study. No mapped controls are shown. IAM recommender 2: Apply and dismiss actions are logged, and Policy Analyzer serves audit tasks. No compliance framework is named.
What would change this ranking
P0 Security would move ahead of Google Cloud IAM recommender if its score on removes access rose by 4 points (from 5 to 9) with nothing else changing. A score changes only when a sourced fact changes, and every change is listed on the corrections page.
Verdict by situation
Strongest, in one sentence each
- P0 Security
- Grants short-lived, scoped access on request through Slack, CLI or web with approvals, and applies the same runtime authorization to AI agents.
- Google Cloud IAM recommender
- The IAM recommender suggests removing or replacing IAM roles that principals have not used, and Policy Simulator shows the effect of a policy change before it is made.
Related pages