{
 "name": "Least Privilege Index",
 "edition": "2026-11-10",
 "read_date": "2026-11-10",
 "source": "https://ciemtools.com/datasets/",
 "license": "CC BY 4.0",
 "cite": "Cite this line: 'CIEM Tools, The Least Privilege Index, edition 10 Nov 2026, https://ciemtools.com/datasets/'",
 "description": "14 platforms scored 0 to 10 on seven criteria with the public reason and the weight; weighted totals rounded and unrounded.",
 "rows": [
  {
   "rank": 1,
   "joint": "yes",
   "platform": "Sonrai Security",
   "total": "5.2",
   "total_unrounded": "5.200",
   "removes": 5,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "Once the customer deploys it, organization-level policies block unused privileges and quarantine dormant identities automatically. Removal of unused permissions is only suggested.",
   "safe": 5,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "Policies are built from observed usage, in-use permissions are exempted, and the exemption list is shown before deployment. The change is reversible, but it is not described as a simulation of the change.",
   "class": 7,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "Sonrai offers a global default deny in one action, AWS resource control policy (RCP) third-party boundaries at any level, service and region blocks, and organization-level just-in-time access across AWS, GCP and Azure. The RCP feature is AWS only, on the vendor's own material only.",
   "fixed": 4,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Blocked attempts open Slack requests, and changes are recorded in ITSM. There is no pre-production check, and the workflow starts only after the restriction is applied.",
   "coverage": 4,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Identities, including AI agent identities, are enforced at the IAM layer. No network reachability model is described.",
   "native": 7,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "Enforcement uses SCPs, RCPs, Azure RBAC and GCP deny policies, with no proxy, broker or connector. This rests on the vendor's own material only.",
   "audit": 4,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "Session logs support audit, and an ISO 27002 mapping page exists. The SOC 2 report covers the company itself, and framework support is otherwise generic.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 1,
   "joint": "yes",
   "platform": "Act Security",
   "total": "5.2",
   "total_unrounded": "5.150",
   "removes": 3,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "Changes are delivered as infrastructure-as-code pull requests that the customer applies. The product is read-only, and direct enforcement is still under discussion.",
   "safe": 7,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "Each change is tested against a digital twin built from cloud configuration data and run in audit mode against audit-log events before enforcement. This is on the vendor's own material only, and rare dependencies may go untested.",
   "class": 7,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "Act runs broad explicit-deny guardrail campaigns for whole attack categories and explicit-allow ring-fencing, applied at the AWS Organizations and SCP level. This is on the vendor's own material only.",
   "fixed": 4,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Act documents drift detection with a diff against cloud versions, a one-line CI/CD blocking claim that does not say what is checked, and a Terraform provider for its own configuration. Exception handling in the customer's tools and rollback are credited only as roadmap or open discussion. Wiz and Sonrai also score 4.",
   "coverage": 6,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "One model combines identity, network, resource and organization controls with configured, effective and observed access, plus endpoint and cloud AI agents. Customer evidence for AI is less mature.",
   "native": 6,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "Act enforces through named native controls (security groups, NSGs, SCPs, RCPs, private endpoints) delivered via infrastructure as code, with no new infrastructure. For AI agents it also enforces on the agent and the gateway.",
   "audit": 3,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "Act names NIST 800-53, PCI DSS and HIPAA as boundaries it enforces. No mapped controls or continuous evidence are described.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 3,
   "joint": "no",
   "platform": "Google Cloud IAM recommender",
   "total": "4.0",
   "total_unrounded": "3.950",
   "removes": 4,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "A person checks and applies role recommendations in the product. Organization policy recommendations are suggestions only.",
   "safe": 6,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "Simulators show how an allow-policy change affects principals' access, and list resources that would violate a proposed organization policy before enforcement. Each simulator covers one policy type, and only Google Cloud.",
   "class": 3,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "Simulators exist for deny and Principal Access Boundary policies, and organization policies are recommended, but clean-up is done role by role.",
   "fixed": 2,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Recommendation states are tracked inside the product. The pre-deploy Terraform check is a separate tool, and no ticketing or chat integration was found.",
   "coverage": 4,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Identity role recommendations and a VPC Service Controls troubleshooter are provided. No AI workloads are covered.",
   "native": 5,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "A recommendation is an operation that removes a member from native IAM policy bindings. It works in one cloud only.",
   "audit": 2,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "Apply and dismiss actions are logged, and Policy Analyzer serves audit tasks. No compliance framework is named.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 4,
   "joint": "no",
   "platform": "Apono",
   "total": "3.9",
   "total_unrounded": "3.850",
   "removes": 5,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "Just-in-time access is created at request time and revoked automatically. Fixes for standing access (delete or right-size) are code that the user runs.",
   "safe": 3,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "A preview of who gets what access is shown before access-flow changes are saved, which is a narrow slice. Remediation actions have no simulation, and some fixes are code the user runs.",
   "class": 3,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "Apono can quarantine a single principal with an AWS permission boundary. Deny policies for overprivileged policies are created by the user, and right-sizing is done per flow.",
   "fixed": 3,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Requests and approvals run in Slack, Teams, the CLI and Terraform-defined flows. No pre-production check or drift handling is described.",
   "coverage": 4,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Identity and AI agents are governed together, with runtime intent checks. No network reachability model is described.",
   "native": 5,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "Permissions are written in the native policy languages of AWS, Azure and GCP. A connector mediates grants, and whether a gateway sits in the request path is not established.",
   "audit": 4,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "Requests, grants and revocations are logged with context, and programs such as SOC 2, HIPAA, GDPR and PCI DSS are named. No control mapping is shown.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 5,
   "joint": "no",
   "platform": "Britive",
   "total": "3.5",
   "total_unrounded": "3.450",
   "removes": 5,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "Just-in-time privilege is created and removed automatically when the task ends, named for AWS, Azure, GCP and OCI.",
   "safe": 1,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "Only a policy Validate button and profile-data validation exist. No impact simulation is described.",
   "class": 3,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "A profile can be associated with OUs or accounts, which scopes just-in-time grants, but there is no deny or boundary and each profile holds one role.",
   "fixed": 3,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Requests run in Slack and Teams, with generic CI/CD and ITSM integrations. No pre-production policy check or drift handling is described.",
   "coverage": 4,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Britive maps human, agentic AI and non-human identities and their privileges. No network reachability model is described.",
   "native": 5,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "The decision is enforced natively at the resource, agentless and proxyless, but the MCP gateway sits in the path of agent calls.",
   "audit": 4,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "Britive names SOC 2, PCI DSS v4.0, NYDFS and HIPAA, and offers a queryable audit trail of grants. No control mapping is shown.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 6,
   "joint": "no",
   "platform": "Wiz",
   "total": "3.4",
   "total_unrounded": "3.400",
   "removes": 3,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "Wiz generates plans, policies and pull requests sent to code owners. A generated fix is not an applied control.",
   "safe": 4,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "Wiz evaluates historical activity to judge disruption before remediation. This is not a simulation of control changes, and infrequent dependencies are not covered.",
   "class": 1,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "Only a limit is documented: translation into durable cross-cloud controls is unvalidated.",
   "fixed": 4,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Policies across the IDE, pull requests and CI/CD can block unsafe changes, and Jira tickets are created. Exceptions, drift and paths outside the pipeline lack evidence.",
   "coverage": 6,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "A graph connects identities, permissions, network exposure, workloads and data into reachable attack paths, plus AI model and agent discovery. AI coverage is inventory rather than reachability.",
   "native": 2,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "Wiz abstracts requirements from provider technology. Whether its output is a native preventive control is left open.",
   "audit": 6,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "Automated compliance covers PCI, GDPR, HIPAA and custom frameworks, with auditor reports. This rests on the vendor's own material only.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 7,
   "joint": "no",
   "platform": "Tenable Cloud Security",
   "total": "3.2",
   "total_unrounded": "3.200",
   "removes": 5,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "Time-limited just-in-time permissions replace standing privilege. Right-sizing policies are applied by the user, and remediation workflows do not say who applies them.",
   "safe": 3,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "The product shows the diff between a generated policy and the current one. No simulation against the environment is described.",
   "class": 0,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "None found on 2026-11-10 after checking 19 pages.",
   "fixed": 4,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Infrastructure-as-code template scanning is offered, with tickets and approvals in Jira, Slack and Teams. No exception or drift handling is described.",
   "coverage": 5,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Identity across AWS, Azure and GCP and overprivileged AI identities are covered. Network coverage is limited to public-accessibility context.",
   "native": 0,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "None found on 2026-11-10 after checking 19 pages.",
   "audit": 5,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "Continuous detection is aligned to CIS, NIST and PCI DSS. No detail on evidence export is given.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 8,
   "joint": "no",
   "platform": "P0 Security",
   "total": "3.1",
   "total_unrounded": "3.050",
   "removes": 5,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "Just-in-time access is provisioned and revoked automatically, with history. Posture findings get suggested shell commands only.",
   "safe": 0,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "None found on 2026-11-10 after checking 20 pages.",
   "class": 2,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "A deny-all policy blocks access requests made through the product for an account. It is not a cloud boundary.",
   "fixed": 3,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Requests arrive through Slack, findings go to Jira, and a Terraform provider exists. No pre-production check or drift handling is described.",
   "coverage": 4,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Identities across several clouds and MCP agent calls are covered. The documentation states that network reachability is not addressed.",
   "native": 5,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "Default paths are agentless on native IAM, with session-bound roles in AWS and GCP. The AI Gateway sits in the agent data path, and connectors broker just-in-time access.",
   "audit": 3,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "P0 provides a full action-chain audit trail and a SOC 2 case study. No mapped controls are shown.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 9,
   "joint": "no",
   "platform": "AWS IAM Access Analyzer",
   "total": "3.0",
   "total_unrounded": "3.000",
   "removes": 3,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "Refined policies and delete links are generated, and the user attaches or deletes them.",
   "safe": 4,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "The tool previews a policy's effect on public and cross-account access and checks new access against the existing version. It does not simulate the impact of removal, and generated policies omit data events and PassRole.",
   "class": 1,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "Access Analyzer only reads RCPs. No boundary generation is listed.",
   "fixed": 4,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Custom policy checks run before deployment in CI/CD and can trigger approval workflows. No drift or exception handling was found.",
   "coverage": 2,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Only identity unused access and resource-based policies are covered. No network or AI model is covered.",
   "native": 4,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "It generates native IAM policies from CloudTrail and is not in the request path. It works in one cloud only, and the user applies the result.",
   "audit": 2,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "A Security Hub control linked to CIS only checks that an analyzer exists. No evidence from findings is provided.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 10,
   "joint": "no",
   "platform": "CrowdStrike",
   "total": "2.9",
   "total_unrounded": "2.850",
   "removes": 3,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "CrowdStrike generates least-privilege and resource-based policies and says it removes unwanted access, but recommendations are what is described as output.",
   "safe": 4,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "CrowdStrike states a dry-run simulation of remediation before deployment, without saying what it runs against.",
   "class": 0,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "None found on 2026-11-10 after checking 16 pages.",
   "fixed": 4,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Infrastructure-as-code scanning runs in CI/CD, the IDE and MCP, and Kubernetes admission can block. No exception or drift handling was found.",
   "coverage": 4,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Identity entitlements and AI security posture management across named AI services are covered. Attack paths do not name network reachability.",
   "native": 0,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "None found on 2026-11-10 after checking 17 pages.",
   "audit": 6,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "CrowdStrike names CIS, NIST, ISO, PCI DSS, HIPAA and FedRAMP, with audit-ready status and scheduled reports. This rests on the vendor's own material only.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 11,
   "joint": "yes",
   "platform": "Entitle",
   "total": "2.8",
   "total_unrounded": "2.750",
   "removes": 5,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "Elevated access is revoked automatically after a set duration, a ticket or a rotation, and approvers can take bulk actions on identities.",
   "safe": 0,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "None found on 2026-11-10 after checking 15 pages.",
   "class": 2,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "Birthright policies and access policies apply request settings across many resources. There is no deny or boundary.",
   "fixed": 3,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Ticketing fulfilment, a Terraform provider and REST APIs are offered. No pre-production check or drift handling is described.",
   "coverage": 4,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Identity access is covered, along with a statement that AI agent functions need a human check for sensitive resources. No network model is described.",
   "native": 2,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "Access is provisioned through the vendor's own VPC agent, which has outbound access, and an API sidecar.",
   "audit": 3,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "Evidence for access certifications is collected automatically. No framework mapping is shown, and the SOC 2 report covers the company itself.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 11,
   "joint": "yes",
   "platform": "Sysdig",
   "total": "2.8",
   "total_unrounded": "2.750",
   "removes": 3,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "Sysdig generates least-privilege policies and infrastructure-as-code fix pull requests. The user validates and applies them.",
   "safe": 2,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "Recommendations are claimed to be non-disruptive, and AI agent policies start in alert mode. No simulation step is described.",
   "class": 0,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "None found on 2026-11-10 after checking 17 pages.",
   "fixed": 4,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Infrastructure-as-code scanning at commit, pull request and CI/CD can fail builds. No exception handling in the team's tools and no drift handling were found.",
   "coverage": 4,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Identity usage comes from audit logs, and an AI agent inventory is included. Attack paths do not name network reachability.",
   "native": 3,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "For cloud, the output is a generated IAM policy that the user applies. Agent enforcement uses the product's own kernel-level host software.",
   "audit": 6,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "Infrastructure-as-code policies are mapped to CIS, NIST 800-53, SOC 2, PCI DSS, HIPAA and ISO 27001, with continuous assessments. This rests on the vendor's own material only.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 13,
   "joint": "no",
   "platform": "Prisma Cloud",
   "total": "2.6",
   "total_unrounded": "2.550",
   "removes": 3,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "IAM fixes are CLI commands the user runs, or a script the user configures. There is no GCP auto-remediation.",
   "safe": 0,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "None found on 2026-11-10 after checking 19 pages.",
   "class": 1,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "Prisma Cloud only reads SCPs as input. It does not create organization-level guardrails.",
   "fixed": 4,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Pull request scans fail at a threshold, alerts go to ServiceNow and Slack, and requests run through ServiceNow. No drift or exception handling was found.",
   "coverage": 5,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Effective permissions across clouds are covered, with a separate network path analyzer. AI agents are covered only by a general statement.",
   "native": 3,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "Remediation runs as native CLI commands that the user executes, with no proxy. It is manual.",
   "audit": 5,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "Built-in standards include NIST 800-53, HIPAA, ISO 27001 and SOC 2. Continuous evidence is not described.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 14,
   "joint": "no",
   "platform": "Microsoft",
   "total": "1.8",
   "total_unrounded": "1.800",
   "removes": 2,
   "removes_weight": 25,
   "removes_reason": "Microsoft is scored on cloud infrastructure entitlement management (CIEM) in Defender for Cloud, because Entra Permissions Management was retired on 2025-11-01 and has not been sold since 2025-04-01. Defender for Cloud CIEM gives recommendations described as guidance for remediating, and from 2026-08-06 no longer publishes unused-action details for AWS.",
   "safe": 0,
   "safe_weight": 20,
   "safe_reason": "Microsoft is scored on cloud infrastructure entitlement management (CIEM) in Defender for Cloud, because Entra Permissions Management was retired on 2025-11-01 and has not been sold since 2025-04-01. None found on 2026-11-10 for Defender for Cloud.",
   "class": 1,
   "class_weight": 15,
   "class_reason": "Microsoft is scored on cloud infrastructure entitlement management (CIEM) in Defender for Cloud, because Entra Permissions Management was retired on 2025-11-01 and has not been sold since 2025-04-01. What remains is Azure Policy, a separate Azure service assigned to management groups and not described as acting on CIEM findings.",
   "fixed": 2,
   "fixed_weight": 15,
   "fixed_reason": "Only IaC misconfiguration correlation is documented, and ITSM integration was presented as roadmap.",
   "coverage": 6,
   "coverage_weight": 10,
   "coverage_reason": "Identity across three clouds, network connections and internet exposure in the security graph, and AI agents in attack paths are covered. AI coverage is stated only briefly.",
   "native": 0,
   "native_weight": 10,
   "native_reason": "Microsoft is scored on cloud infrastructure entitlement management (CIEM) in Defender for Cloud, because Entra Permissions Management was retired on 2025-11-01 and has not been sold since 2025-04-01. None found on 2026-11-10 for Defender for Cloud.",
   "audit": 5,
   "audit_weight": 5,
   "audit_reason": "Continuous assessment runs against compliance controls, with export and Purview integration. Non-default standards need a paid plan, and none are named.",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  }
 ]
}