Skip to content
CIEM Tools

CIEM vs CSPM: CSPM checks how cloud resources are configured, CIEM checks what identities can do with them

CSPM assesses cloud assets against security standards and reports misconfigurations, while CIEM examines what identities are permitted to do and what they used. Microsoft sells its CIEM capabilities inside the Defender CSPM plan, and its Foundational CSPM tier is free, per pages read on 16 Nov 2026.

See the ranking ยท All guides

CSPM checks configuration, CIEM checks permissions

Microsoft's documentation defines Cloud Security Posture Management as continuous visibility into the security state of cloud assets and workloads, with recommendations to reduce misconfigurations in Azure, AWS and Google Cloud. The unit of work is a resource and a setting: a storage account, a network rule, an encryption flag.

Wiz, a vendor, defines CIEM as the practice of discovering, analyzing and controlling what identities in a cloud environment can actually do. Its guidance says CIEM calculates effective permissions by resolving role assignments, group membership, role assumption and trust relationships into one view. The unit of work is an identity and what it can reach.

A simple contrast shows the split. A storage bucket that is readable from the internet is a configuration finding, and a posture tool should catch it. A service account that can read every bucket in the organization is a permissions finding, and a posture check on the bucket will not show it, because each bucket is configured correctly. See entitlement and excess permission for the terms.

The two overlap on identity settings and share a product

Microsoft's Defender for Cloud page on CIEM says the capabilities sit inside the Defender CSPM plan. It lists support for Microsoft Entra ID users, groups and service principals, AWS IAM users, roles and groups, and Google Cloud IAM users, groups and service accounts. Its recommendations include removing inactive, guest or blocked accounts, right-sizing permissions for overprovisioned identities, and enforcing MFA on IAM users. The last of these is a posture check that happens to concern identity, which is where the two categories blur.

Microsoft's pricing page, read on 16 Nov 2026, describes Foundational CSPM as free and says Defender CSPM billing is based on counts of servers, storage accounts, databases, serverless containers and serverless resources. That means the CIEM extension is priced by the size of the cloud estate, not by the number of identities. Compare that with the unit used by AWS for its unused access analyzer, in the CIEM pricing page.

What each category answers, side by side

The rows are a summary of the definitions above, not a test result. Products from the same vendor often present both in one console, so the label on the module is a weak guide. The question to ask is what the module computes.

QuestionCSPM answers itCIEM answers it
Is this storage account open to the internet?Yes, a configuration checkOnly as context for an identity path
Which service account can read production data?Not in its definitionYes, from effective permissions
Which roles went unused for 90 days?Not in its definitionYes (Google's IAM recommender uses a 90-day window)
Is MFA enforced on IAM users?Yes, a posture checkSometimes, as an identity recommendation
Can a compromised workload reach the database?Partly, through network rulesYes, when joined with network context

The five CNAPP platforms on this index score 2.6 to 3.4

Five of the 14 platforms on this index are CNAPPs that include entitlement management: Wiz at 3.4, Tenable Cloud Security at 3.2, CrowdStrike at 2.9, Sysdig at 2.8 and Prisma Cloud at 2.6 on the main view. Their strength is context: the same console already holds vulnerabilities, network exposure and data location, which Wiz argues makes identity findings easier to prioritize.

The index ranks by the access a product removes. Sonrai Security and Act share first at 5.2, with Sonrai listed first because it is ahead before rounding (5.20 against 5.15). Act is not a CNAPP: it does not scan workloads or vulnerabilities (none found on 2026-11-10), and it publishes no pricing. It also does not make the change itself: it has read-only access to your cloud and delivers each change as a pull request to your Terraform or CloudFormation, or as a ticket, for your team to apply, and handling of violations and time-bound waivers after a change ships was described as roadmap. The head-to-head Act vs Wiz shows the seven scores side by side, and the method explains how they were set.

If you already pay for a CSPM or CNAPP, test its CIEM module first against the points in the CIEM requirements checklist. If the module only reports, a second tool may be needed to remove access.

Sources

  1. Microsoft Learn, what is Cloud Security Posture Management, read 16 Nov 2026
  2. Microsoft Learn, CIEM in Defender for Cloud, read 16 Nov 2026
  3. Microsoft Azure, Defender for Cloud pricing, read 16 Nov 2026
  4. Wiz Academy, how to choose a CIEM vendor, read 16 Nov 2026
  5. Google Cloud, IAM role recommendations overview, read 16 Nov 2026

Last reviewed 16 Nov 2026.