Skip to content
CIEM Tools

CIEM tools find excess access in four different ways and finish the job in only some of them

Cloud infrastructure entitlement management tools compare granted access with used access across cloud accounts. On this index they fall into four groups: permissions firewalls, just-in-time access tools, CNAPP modules and provider tools. The groups differ most in who removes the access once it is found.

See the ranking ยท All guides

What CIEM is

Tenable's account of the term is that Gartner introduced cloud infrastructure entitlement management in 2020 to describe the next generation of solutions for managing access and enforcing least privilege in the cloud. Tenable argues that identity governance and privileged access tools were built for human access to enterprise resources and fall short in public cloud, where developers grant broad entitlements to people and infrastructure to keep delivery moving.

In practice a CIEM tool inventories identities, entitlements and resources, compares what is granted with what is used, and reports the gap. Wiz describes the output as effective permissions, resolving relationships into a view of what identities can do in reality, not what policy documents say. The categories below differ in what they do next. Pricing, deployment and the clouds covered differ too, so read each platform profile for its sources.

Permissions firewalls

A permissions firewall turns the usage gap into a block. Sonrai Security is the example on this index. Sonrai says its Cloud Permissions Firewall blocks unused privileged permissions, quarantines dormant identities and restricts third-party access through organization-level, cloud-native policies, and restores access through ChatOps approvals in Slack, Teams or email. The ChatOps loop matters because a block with no way to ask for access back would push engineers to bypass the control.

Sonrai also says enforcement uses the cloud's own policy types with no proxy or broker, and that nothing enforces until the customer deploys the policies. Act sits near this group by outcome, since the changes it proposes remove classes of access, but it is read-only and delivers changes as pull requests or tickets for the customer to apply. Sonrai's own materials say its Slack workflow starts after a restriction is in place, when an identity tries a restricted permission.

Just-in-time access tools

These tools attack standing access rather than unused access. Apono, Britive, P0 Security and Entitle describe granting access on request for a limited time and removing it afterward, with approvals in tools such as Slack. Britive and Apono each describe zero standing privileges as a goal on their sites, and Apono lists break-glass access among its flows. Entitle describes approvals in Slack and Teams, and P0 Security describes requests through Slack, a CLI or the web.

Just-in-time access shrinks what an attacker finds at any moment, and it fits teams whose main exposure is human administrators. It does less for the permanent permissions that workloads hold, where the question is what a role uses, not who asks. The index ranks these tools on the same seven criteria as the others, so a good request workflow does not hide a weak showing on class-level change. Compare each tool on the criteria rather than on the workflow alone.

CNAPP modules

Wiz, Tenable Cloud Security, Prisma Cloud, CrowdStrike and Sysdig include entitlement analysis inside a broader cloud security platform. Their strength is context: the same graph that holds vulnerabilities and exposure also holds identities, so a permission can be ranked by whether the workload is reachable and sensitive. Wiz and Tenable both say their platforms reveal toxic combinations across misconfigurations, identities and data. Sysdig says it uses runtime data to show which permissions are in use. Context is the real contribution of this group, since the entitlement finding arrives with exposure attached.

The trade-off is that the entitlement module is one product among many, and the output is typically a prioritized finding. Posture and CNAPP rankings as such are outside this index, which scores these products only on how much access they remove. Compare them on removal and not on the number of findings. Tenable's own description is that it combines CIEM and JIT access with posture management, IaC scanning and attack paths.

Provider tools

AWS IAM Access Analyzer, the Google Cloud IAM recommender and Microsoft's CIEM extension in Defender for Cloud come from the cloud provider. AWS and Google Cloud tools cover their own cloud, and Microsoft's extension also reads AWS and Google Cloud. They are good at the usage gap: unused roles, keys and permissions, and policy templates from logs. Each provider says the user applies the result. Treat their output as the baseline that any paid platform has to improve on.

Microsoft's separate Entra Permissions Management was retired, as the retirement guide explains. Provider tools make a sound first step before a purchase. The method shows how each group scored across removal, safety, class-level change and the other criteria. Microsoft names the Defender CIEM extension as the route for customers of the retired product.

Match the category to the exposure

If the main risk is a handful of human administrators with permanent rights, just-in-time access addresses it directly. If the risk is thousands of workload roles with broad grants, you need usage-based removal and class-level boundaries. If you already run a CNAPP, test its entitlement module before you buy another product. The five situation pages on this index apply different weights to the same scores.

Whichever category you pick, write down who will apply the changes. A report with no owner to apply it ends where findings-only tools end, in a queue. The score for removal in the method exists to separate the products that finish the job from those that hand it back. Ask each shortlisted vendor to show one completed removal in an environment like yours.

Sources

  1. Tenable blog, protect applications and data with CIEM, read 10 Nov 2026
  2. Wiz Academy, how to choose a CIEM vendor, read 10 Nov 2026
  3. Sonrai Security, platform page, read 10 Nov 2026
  4. Apono, home page, read 10 Nov 2026
  5. P0 Security documentation, read 10 Nov 2026
  6. Entitle, home page, read 10 Nov 2026
  7. Sysdig, CIEM solution page, read 10 Nov 2026
  8. Britive, about page, read 10 Nov 2026
  9. Tenable Cloud Security, read 10 Nov 2026
  10. AWS, what is IAM Access Analyzer, read 10 Nov 2026
  11. Microsoft Learn, CIEM in Defender for Cloud, read 10 Nov 2026

Last reviewed 16 Nov 2026.